Skip to content
Durham Region, Ontario
Daily Durham
Subscribe
Back to the latest

Durham Region / News

Appeal court orders new trial in malicious-prosecution case against Durham police board

The Ontario Court of Appeal has ordered a new trial limited to a malicious-prosecution claim against the Durham Regional Police Services Board, calling two jury verdicts unsafe.

Osgoode Hall, home of the Ontario Court of Appeal, in snow. File photo.
Osgoode Hall in Toronto, home of the Ontario Court of Appeal. (File photo: David Whelan, Wikimedia Commons, CC0) · Credit: David Whelan / Wikimedia Commons, CC0

The Ontario Court of Appeal has ordered a new trial limited to a malicious-prosecution claim against the Durham Regional Police Services Board and two constables, Law Times News reports.

Source: www.lawtimesnews.com

The case, Sanayhie v. Durham (Police Services Board), 2026 ONCA 813, stems from an incident in the early hours of December 22, 2015, when police removed a man from a Tim Hortons, the report says. The man alleged wrongful arrest, excessive force and malicious prosecution over charges of assault with intent to resist arrest and assault causing bodily harm.

A jury tried the civil action in January 2025 and returned two verdicts: the first found no liability for malicious prosecution but fixed damages for that claim, while a second verdict, after the trial judge re-instructed the jury, found liability and imposed damages in the same amount, the report says.

On June 26, 2025, Justice Michael K. McKelvey of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice dismissed the appellants' motion and entered judgment according to the second verdict, the report says. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and set aside the trial judgment on the malicious-prosecution claim, including punitive damages and legal costs, the report says.

Writing for the appeal court, Justice Peter D. Lauwers called the first verdict unclear and therefore unsafe, and found the second verdict unsafe because the trial judge's re-instruction suggested the jury find malicious prosecution, the report says. The court also found the jury instructions did not track the jury questions. None of the allegations have been proven in court, and the new trial is limited to the malicious-prosecution claim.

Behind the story

Sources & publication details

Byline
Daily Durham News
Published
Nov 18, 2026, 4:18 p.m.
Source
www.lawtimesnews.com

The Durham brief

A little closer to home.

Local stories worth knowing, straight to your inbox.